Claudia Moscovici
02.01.2017

The Dangerous Seducer in Literature (II)

Benjamin Constant’s Adolphe

As we’ve seen, psychopaths commonly foster their victims’ dependency in order to control them. They tend to move very fast, in a race against time. Brown exposes the strategic logic behind this seemingly passionate rush:

The rapid pace that psychopaths are known to have in relationship skill building will move her quickly into gorilla-glue bonding at lightning speed (Women Who Love Psychopaths, 156).

Any fast-paced romantic relationship with a psychopath inevitably turns into a train wreck. Ellénore’s affair with Adolphe is no exception. Unfortunately for her and those who care about her, the heroine gives in to her lover’s unrelenting pressure. Like Mme Bovary and Anna Karenina, seen from the external perspective of the implied reader, Ellénore is not a particularly sympathetic character. She readily abandons her values and obligations to others for the sake of ephemeral pleasures with a cheap seducer. She falls victim not only to Adolphe’s machinations, but also to her own vanity and selfish tendencies. Psychopaths intuitively know how to use their victims’ character flaws against them. Like so many women seduced by emotional predators, Ellénore is addicted to the narcissistic supply that only her lover gives her, which, during the seduction phase, makes her feel more special, more desirable and more interesting than other women. Adolphe sees that his persistence and false promises have paid off. “Ellénore never knew until now this passionate sentiment, this feeling of another being lost in her existence, which even my anger and frustration proved to her” (59).

Just as he’s open-eyed about his target’s vulnerabilities, Adolphe remains lucid about the fact that the process of seduction itself excites him, not Ellénore herself. He observes, “Her resistance intensified all my sensations, all my thoughts: I experienced anger which frightened her and moved her to submission, tenderness and idolatrous veneration” (59). Only Ellénore confuses her lover’s intense pursuit and bullying persistence with genuine caring. More generally, she misconstrues his goal of seduction for the goal of building an enduring relationship together. Acting upon this false assumption, “she abandoned herself completely” (59).

While Adolphe experiences casual fondness for his new mistress and takes pleasure in her company, his attachment to her is only temporary and superficial. Emotional predators tend to view sex as their preferred vehicle of exercising dominance. For a psychopathic seducer like Adolphe, once the conquest is over, so is the thrill of the chase. The lesser pleasure of ownership replaces the intense rush of seduction: “I walked with pride among men; I looked them over with a domineering glance” (59).

Psychopaths live passion only in the moment. At this point in the narrative, Constant gives voice to the most lyrical description I’ve read of the psychopathic bond: of this highly contingent and conditional yet often intense form of passion that makes the present seem eternal. The narrator declares, “Love is nothing but a luminous point of light, and yet it seems to extend throughout time. A few days ago it didn’t exist, soon it won’t exist anymore; but, for as long as it lasts, it spreads its clarity upon both past and future” (56). For a psychopathic seducer, however, the present moment casts very little light upon the past and the future. Memories of wonderful times shared together or of overcoming common hardships don’t sediment for such shallow individuals. Therefore, they also don’t create a foundation of real intimacy. Likewise, hopes for the future mean nothing to them without the intense pleasures of the moment. When you remove the significance of a common past as well as future commitment from human experience, all you have left is a tainted, and increasingly tedious, present.

Once no longer distracted by the goal pursuing Ellénore, Adolphe feels inconvenienced by his new mistress’ demands. He remains flattered by her love. But her excessive attention has an obvious downside now, which never bothered him before, when he was euphoric with the rush of pursuing her. As Ellénore’s attachment to him grows with contact, Adolphe’s attraction to her proportionately diminishes. The narrator observes, “Her attachment to me seemed to increase from the sacrifice she made me. She never let me go without trying to retain me. When I left, she asked me when I’d return… It was sometimes inconvenient to have all my steps measured in advance and all my minutes counted” (59). What turns out to be most “inconvenient” for the seducer is the fact that he has to break up with most of his “acquaintances”—code word for his other lovers and flings—since Ellénore is a much more high-maintenance mistress. To his chagrin, she demands most of his time and attention in exchange for her devotion.

At this point, Adolphe is still “in love” with Ellénore. But there’s a palpable difference between the cool satisfaction he feels now and the hot passion of his initial pursuit. He depicts the distinction eloquently and succinctly when he states, “Ellénore was no doubt still a lively pleasure in my life, but she was no longer a goal, she was a bond” (62). That’s not a very good thing to be, at least from the perspective of a psychopathic seducer. A bond is someone or something that restrains his behavior. Psychopaths want to enchain others and gain total control of their lives. But they, themselves, need to remain free. Love bonds can be exclusive because they’re grounded in mutual caring. By way of contrast, the dominance bonds psychopaths establish with their targets aren’t exclusive. Once a psychopathic seducer conquers a woman, she also loses most of his interest.

Unfortunately for their unsuspecting victims, psychopaths rarely admit the selfishness, malice and cynicism that motivate their relentless pursuit of women. While during the seduction phase they commonly argue in favor of violating social mores, once they tire of their targets they appeal to the very norms that they repeatedly transgress and don’t even believe in. Conveniently, Adolphe rationalizes his diminished interest in Ellénore in terms of his concern for her social reputation: “I feared moreover compromising her. My constant presence must have astonished her servants, her children, who could see me. I trembled at the idea of unsettling her life” (62). Funny that he should think of his mistress’ reputation only now, after having used her. It never occurred to him to consider Ellénore’s partner, her children and her place in society before, when she was pointing out to him all these factors as reasons not to get romantically involved. As we recall, at that time Adolphe viewed them as nothing more than obstacles in his path.

It’s not exactly a cosmic coincidence that once a psychopath attains his goal, he suddenly changes rhetoric and becomes conventional. The narrator makes it transparently obvious that once seduced, Ellénore no longer attracts him. He attempts to detach himself from his mistress so that he can be free, once again, to pursue other women. Being emotionally hooked on him and believing in his disingenuous love, however, Ellénore holds on to her lover with all her might. Adolphe’s impatience to move on is only mollified by the idea that the liaison with Ellénore is, after all, temporary: “At any rate the vague ideal that, by the nature of things, this affair couldn’t last… served to calm me when I got tired or impatient with her” (62). Adolphe sees the end of their affair as the light at the end of the tunnel. By way of contrast, Ellénore views him as the light of her life.

Adolphe’s diminished interest in his mistress after having seduced her doesn’t necessarily prove that he’s a psychopath. As many women will tell you, there are millions of emotionally unavailable or shallow men, who view “love” as a sequence of exciting hook-ups. Fortunately for the rest of society, however, most of them aren’t clinically psychopathic. Usually, they’re out to have a good time, not to control and emotionally destroy their targets. What makes a psychopath far more dangerous than your ordinary player is the fact that an emotional predator doesn’t want his targets to escape from his clutches unharmed. Players may, more or less unwittingly, leave behind a trail of broken hearts. They’re generally indifferent to the welfare of their “scores.” Psychopaths, on the other hand, deliberately and maliciously harm their targets. They leave behind a trail of shattered lives.

On some level, psychopaths suffer from incurable addictions, even to the targets they no longer desire. Although he’s grown tired of Ellénore, Adolphe can’t detach from his own dominance bond with her. This establishes between them an unhealthy co-dependency, which becomes increasingly burdensome to him and extremely dangerous for her: “Her happiness was necessary to me and I knew I was necessary to her happiness” (62). Of course, what the narrator goes on to describe is anything but happiness. Because both characters seem unwilling (or unable) to let each other go, literary critics generally take the author at his word. They view Adolphe as a man who lacks the strength to break his mistress’ heart, even after having fallen out of love with her. I don’t see much evidence for this interpretation in the novel, however. Instead, I recognize in Adolphe’s language and behavior the kind of rationalizations psychopaths commonly make for keeping their victims on the hook long after the thrill of seduction, and thus their so-called “passion,” is nothing but a distant memory.

Adolphe’s unwillingness to tell Ellénore the truth—namely, that he tired of her and wants to move on to someone else—functions as a form of psychological torture for her. She can’t understand why she lost his “love.” She therefore doesn’t know what to do to prove herself worthy of Adolphe’s devotion once again. Like many of the real women who love psychopaths, Ellénore clings to the memories of Adolphe’s supposed passion. She refuses to confront his obvious lack of caring for her. Sandra L. Brown, M.A. attributes this bracketing of unpleasant realities in the psychopathic bond to the trance-like focus encouraged by the psychopath during the seduction phase: “Trance produces perceptual biases. That means if the psychopath is telling her wonderful things and she is euphoric with him, she tends to associate wonderful and euphoric things with the memory of him… even after he’s turned into a monster” (Women Who Love Psychopaths, 181).

Trusting those misleading memories over real actions, Ellénore hopelessly struggles to reclaim Adolphe’s affection. Yet nothing she does proves good enough for him. She abandons her partner. She leaves her children under the custody of Comte de P. She refuses the fortune the count offers her on the condition that she leaves her unprincipled lover. She gives up what’s left of her social circle to follow her lover wherever he wants to go. She invites him to live with her at her expense in her native country, Poland, once she receives an inheritance from her father. The list of sacrifices she makes to regain the seducer’s “love” goes on and on. By the end, it starts to resemble the absurdity of one of Voltaire’s farces. Ellénore mistakenly believes that the more she gives up for Adolphe, the more he’ll grow to appreciate her sacrifices. In fact, the opposite logic applies. The more she gives in to him, the more he asks of her. As she struggles to meet his new needs, these shift.

Seeking dominance rather than successful relationships, psychopaths enjoy watching their partners jump through hoops for them. They can’t appreciate or reciprocate feelings of devotion, self-sacrifice or love. Consequently, they often prey upon women who play the martyr role, taking everything they give and offering them less and less in return. In fact, the more power a psychopath acquires over a given target, the less she interests him and, therefore, the fewer concessions he makes for her.

After the seduction phase, joint life between Adolphe and Ellénore turns into a game of simulation. He pretends to care about her while she, in turn, pretends to be happy with their increasingly distant relationship. The less effort the seducer makes to keep on his phony mask of charm, the more his true identity and ugly motives show through. As a result, their relationship degenerates into a series of explosive fights and mutual reproaches, punctuated by periodic reconciliations: “We exploded in mutual reproaches. Ellénore accused me of having misled her, of not having had for her anything but a passing infatuation and having alienated the count’s affection, having placed her in the compromising social situation which she had tried all her life to escape” (65).

Susan Forward wittily states in her best-selling book on misogynist men, Men Who Hate Women and the Women Who Love Them, that when the honeymoon phase of a romantic relationship is over, it’s over for both partners. One of them doesn’t get to stay in Hawaii while the other one returns home. Both Adolphe and Ellénore become dissatisfied with their hollow relationship. Perfunctory reconciliations after fights can’t erase the fact that they both realize that his feelings for her are gone. “We kissed: but the first blow was delivered, a first barrier was crossed. Both of us spoke irreparable words; we could remain quiet, but not forget them” (65). During such moments, even Ellénore opens her eyes to catch a glimpse of the unpleasant reality. She acknowledges her loss of status in her lover’s eyes. What she refuses to confront, however, is the more disturbing fact that Adolphe never loved her because he’s incapable of love.

Believing that she must have done something to lose his affection, Ellénore clings to her lover with all her might. Predictably, this leads him to withdraw further. “I complained about my constrained life, of my youth consumed by inactivity, of the despotism she exercised over my actions” (70). From the revered queen placed above all other women on a pedestal, Ellénore becomes a slave to her lover’s wishes. She turns into an abject woman who’s pathetically aiming to appease a psychopath so that he can stay in her life. Needless to say, Ellénore’s desperate struggles don’t reignite Adolphe’s initial enthusiasm for her. They only weaken her further, increase his power over her and perpetuate the farce their life together has become. Once again, her behavior conforms to the real responses of many of the women who love psychopaths, who are weakened by their constant efforts to please their pathological partners. Brown documents, “By the mid-part of the relationship a woman who is normally dominant and resourceful may for the first time in her life feel ‘fragile’ or even ‘mentally ill’” (Women Who Love Psychopaths, 214).

Although she keeps jumping through his hoops, Adolphe is not satisfied with the power he has over her. Deprived of any possibility of mutual love, their life together feels rehearsed: “Ellénore and I pretended with one another,” the narrator recounts. “We said nothing about the only thought that obsessed us. We lavished upon one another caresses, we uttered words of love, but we spoke of love out of the fear of speaking of anything else” (70).

Tellingly, only when Adolphe encounters another obstacle—once his father banishes Ellénore and forbids him from seeing her—does he experience a spark of his former passion for his mistress: “I formed thousands of plans to rejoin Ellénore forever: all my heart came back to her; I was proud to protect her. I hungered to hold her in my arms; love repenetrated my soul, I felt a fever which overwhelmed my head, my heart, my senses” (77). This flicker of reawakened emotion, triggered by willfulness rather than love, is quickly extinguished. For once, Ellénore sees through its real motivation and confronts her lover: “She insisted on forcing the truth out of me; her joy disappeared, her face was covered by a dark cloud” (77).

Afterwards, Ellénore and Adolphe fall back upon the only thing they can do, given their pathological interdependency and the absence of mutual love: dissimulation and diversion. Irritated by her reproaches, Adolphe finally confesses to his mistress: “I will always be your friend, I will always feel for you the most profound affection… But love, this transport of the senses, this involuntary inebriation, this forgetfulness of all other interests and duties, Ellénore, I don’t feel them anymore” (77). In admitting to her the truth, Adolphe isn’t motivated by integrity, compassion or honesty. He allows his mask of charm to slip off once he feels that he’s already used up Ellénore’s value. He’s now ready to initiate the discard phase. As Sandra L. Brown, M.A. elaborates, “Psychopaths enjoy power most when it is equated to, and produces, victimization” (Women Who Love Psychopaths, 39).

At this point in the narrative, if Ellénore were strong enough to accept this fact, she would have finally understood that Adolphe’s passion for her was predatory, shallow and ephemeral and moved on with her life. But that wouldn’t make for such a poignant story. It also wouldn’t be as psychologically realistic. Current research on the psychopathic bond shows that many women stay with their dangerous partners and persevere in toxic relationships even after they see the psychopaths for what they are and even after their pleasure and joy together are gone. Instead of letting go of her malicious lover, Ellénore continues trying to resuscitate their comatose relationship. Predictably, none of her strategies work. Adolphe aptly summarizes the emotional vacuum he senses between them: “We lived, if one could call it so, in a kind of memory of the heart, sufficiently strong so that the idea of separation was painful to us, but too weak to give us any pleasure in being together” (85).

To alleviate their mounting tension, Adolphe and Ellénore throw themselves into social life. They also resort to playing mind games with one another. She tries to make him jealous by flirting with other men. “This cold and reserved woman […] seemed to suddenly change personality. She encouraged the feelings and even the hopes of a crowd of young men” (99). But her plan predictably misfires, since having already had her, Adolphe no longer wants to possess her. In addition, he sees through her transparent ploys. Although not genuinely jealous, Adolphe exerts control over his unhappy mistress for its own sake. He asks Ellénore to stop flirting with other men. She instantly obeys, hoping, as before, that her concessions will buy her his love. They don’t, of course. On the contrary, Ellénore’s constant submission to his will bores Adolphe. A defeated, passive conquest presents no further challenge to a psychopathic seducer. The narrator recounts, “Everything around us resumed a normal existence but we were even unhappier. Ellénore thought she had new rights over me; I felt weighed by new chains” (102). The downside of establishing such dominance bonds, at least from the psychopath’s perspective, is that they also constrain the seducer himself.

To make matters worse, Adolphe is blinded by his own delusional narcissism. He imagines that without being tied to his current mistress, he’d be great, rich, successful, sociable, beloved, wealthy and desired by far more distinguished aristocratic women: even though he wasn’t doing anything productive with his life before having met Ellénore. “As stingy men see in the treasure they amass all the goods they could buy with them, so I saw in Ellénore the privation of all the successes I could have without her. It’s not just one career that I regretted. As I hadn’t tried any of them, I regretted them all. Having never used my talents, I imagined them to be limitless; I wished that nature would have made me weak and mediocre to spare me the regret of having sunk so low voluntarily” (89-90).

Having already devalued his victim, Adolphe sets the groundwork to discard her with immunity by criticizing her to others. He damages Ellénore’s tainted reputation further by making misogynist comments to mutual acquaintances. His interlocutors correctly interpret such jabs as aimed at his mistress, not at women in general. “People reproached her for not having inspired in her lover more consideration for her gender and more respect for romantic bonds” (71). He then proceeds to complain about Ellénore more directly to a man who is a friend of his father’s—and thus already biased against her—as well as to his mistress’ best friend. The psychopath’s smear campaign works. Both acquaintances fall for Adolphe’s fake pity play. They spread more nasty rumors about Ellénore.

After having demeaned his mistress and isolated her from everyone who cared about her, the seducer abandons her. When Ellénore discovers a letter Adolphe wrote to his father’s friend, in which he maligns her and promises to leave her, she falls seriously ill. She finally realizes that she has sacrificed everything and everyone in her life for a man who doesn’t even love her. Only then does Adolphe also see that he’ll soon lose the only being over whom he exercised total control. He’s not particularly concerned about Ellénore’s failing health. He worries instead about finding himself alone, deprived of such a willing and malleable target: “I broke the only being who loved me; I broke this heart, this companion, who persisted in devoting herself to me with indefatigable tenderness; already a sense of isolation overcame me. Ellénore was still breathing, but I could no longer confide in her my thoughts, I was already alone in the world, I no longer lived in this atmosphere of love that spread itself around me… The whole of nature seemed to tell me that I ceased to be loved forever” (113-4).

Readers need not worry about Adolphe, however. We can be confident that psychopathic seducers like him will always find plenty of willing victims to attract, use, manipulate and destroy. The death of Ellénore is not a tragedy, just as the story of this failed love affair is not a romance. As much as it’s difficult to believe in Adolphe’s sorrow at the end, it’s difficult to mourn the death of Ellénore. Even though she’s a more sympathetic character than Adolphe, her self-absorption, the neglect of her obligations towards her previous partner and children and her obsessive need for an empty man’s manipulative attention caused her undoing. Yet in some respects, like Emma Bovary and Anna Karenina—two comparably imperfect heroines—Ellénore is an emotionally compelling character that deserves some sympathy. She reflects with stark realism the psychological devastation of victims of emotional predators. She illustrates how psychopaths turn strong and healthy individuals into effigies of their former selves. It’s difficult to comprehend this horrible experience if you haven’t felt it on your own skin. How can anybody have sympathy for someone whose moral framework and dignity have been so seriously undermined that she willingly accepts such a humiliating asymmetrical arrangement and even pines for it when the psychopath inevitably grows tired of her and discards her?

The only way I can answer this question is by suggesting that we should not look at “voluntary” relationships only in terms of a reductive voluntarism. I’ll offer an analogy to explain my point. When the women in Afghanistan “choose” to cover their whole bodies except for their eyes in burkas, when they “choose” a religious ideology which regards them as the property of men in their culture, when they “choose” to forgo education and even basic medical care, it’s because their options of gaining respect in that society are severely restricted. Basically, their “voluntary choice” is to be respected as a proper Muslim woman or not at all. Our choices aren’t open-ended among infinite possibilities. We make life decisions largely based on our temperaments, circumstances, values and, above all, the information we have at our disposal.

When dealing with psychopaths, however, you’re dealing with a steady flow of misinformation, compounded by phony yet often compelling behavior, which distorts your perception of reality and hampers your ability to make rational decisions. Lack of knowledge about personality disorders, false or partial information, brainwashing and the creation of unrealistic expectations all play a significant role in determining women’s poor choices once they’re trapped in psychopathic bonds. Furthermore, with each step they take to get closer to their psychopathic partner and strive to gain his approval, such women become increasingly entangled in a web that narrows the range of their freedom and diminishes the quality of their lives, as Adolphe did for Ellénore. Like her, they can end up prisoners of an unrequited love.

Why is this phenomenon relevant to a general audience and not just to those who have been burned by psychopathic seducers? Because just about anyone can be ensnared by emotional predators. As we’ll see in my discussion of the current research on the women who love psychopaths, psychopathic seduction can happen to anyone, not just to women predisposed to masochism or to those who lack self-esteem. Constant’s novel illustrates that psychopathic seduction happens gradually and in ways that are disguised as true love and mutual caring. Current research shows that it happens to moral and religious women as well as to those with more liberal values. It happens to women of every age, social background and range of education. Information about psychopathy and relationships with emotional predators is the best way to protect yourself against them. Without this information, you may not realize that you’re involved with a dangerous man until it’s too late: until, like the misfortunate Ellénore, you’ve invested far too much for far too long into that toxic relationship. How much are some women willing to sacrifice in the name of “love”? Both fact and fiction tell us that the answer is astonishingly much. Sometimes even everything.